The 2009-S John Tyler Presidential Dollar is worth anywhere from $2 to $10 for most circulated examples, while deep cameo proof versions can fetch $15 to $30 or more depending on grade and eye appeal. If you’ve come across one of these coins, you’re in the right place to learn exactly what it’s worth.
Whether you stumbled across this coin in a collection you inherited or spotted it in a coin box at an estate sale, knowing its value doesn’t have to be complicated. Tools like the best coin identifier app can help you identify and value coins in seconds — even if you’re brand new to coin collecting.
What Is the 2009-S John Tyler Dollar Coin?
The 2009-S John Tyler Dollar is part of the Presidential Dollar series launched by the U.S. Mint in 2007. This program honored American presidents in the order they served, and John Tyler — the 10th president — was among the four presidents featured in 2009. The “S” mint mark tells you this coin was struck at the San Francisco Mint and produced exclusively as a proof coin for collectors. It was never released into general circulation, which makes it a bit more special than its Philadelphia and Denver counterparts. The coin features a sharp, polished portrait of Tyler on the obverse and the Statue of Liberty on the reverse. Proof coins from San Francisco are known for their mirror-like fields and frosted design details, giving them a stunning visual contrast that regular coins simply don’t have.
2009-S Tyler Dollar Value by Grade
Because this coin was only made as a proof, grading follows the PR (proof) scale rather than the standard MS (mint state) scale. Most 2009-S Tyler dollars you’ll find will be in PR65 to PR70 range, since they were handled carefully from the start. Here’s a general value breakdown:
| Grade | Description | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| PR65 | Choice Proof | $4 – $7 |
| PR66 | Gem Proof | $5 – $9 |
| PR67 | Superb Gem Proof | $7 – $12 |
| PR68 | Near Perfect | $10 – $18 |
| PR69 DC | Deep Cameo | $15 – $25 |
| PR70 DC | Perfect Deep Cameo | $25 – $40+ |
A PR70 Deep Cameo example is considered flawless and commands the highest prices from serious collectors. If your coin has been certified by PCGS or NGC at this level, it’s worth getting a second opinion on a recent sale price.
How the 2009-S Tyler Dollar Compares to Other 2009 Presidential Dollars
The 2009 Presidential Dollar series includes four coins: William Henry Harrison, John Tyler, James K. Polk, and Zachary Taylor. Among these, values are fairly similar across the board for standard proof issues. However, if you’re curious about related coins from the same year, you can check out detailed value information for the full 2009 Presidential Dollar series to see how each president’s coin stacks up. Interestingly, the Native American Dollar issued the same year has its own collector following. You can explore current market pricing data for the 2009 Native American Dollar in MS grades to see how the companion series performs in comparison.
How to Check Your 2009-S Tyler Dollar’s Value at Home
You don’t need to be an expert to get a solid estimate of what your coin is worth. Start by examining the coin under good lighting and look for any scratches, spots, or haze on the surface — these will lower the grade. Then check whether your coin is still in its original U.S. Mint proof set packaging, as original packaging can help maintain value. For a fast and accurate reading, many collectors today use CoinHix, a popular app that pulls real-time pricing data and lets you track your collection digitally. CoinHix is especially helpful for presidential dollars since it covers the entire series with updated sales records. If you want to go even further, submitting your coin for professional grading through PCGS or NGC is the gold standard for getting a certified, insured value.
Is the 2009-S Tyler Dollar Worth Keeping?
Honestly, most 2009-S Tyler dollars aren’t going to make you rich overnight. With mintage numbers in the hundreds of thousands and values largely in the single-digit to low double-digit range, these are collector’s pieces more than investment goldmines. That said, they’re beautiful coins with genuine historical significance, and a PR70 DC example is a very respectable addition to any collection. If you’re building a Presidential Dollar collection, this is one you’ll want to have. And if you’re just trying to figure out whether to keep or sell, apps like CoinHix make it easy to track market trends over time so you can make a smart decision.
—
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: How many 2009-S John Tyler Dollars were minted?
A: The U.S. Mint produced approximately 2.2 million 2009-S John Tyler Proof Dollars as part of the Presidential Dollar Proof Set. This is a relatively modest mintage for a modern coin, which helps support collector interest over time.
Q: Can I find the 2009-S Tyler Dollar in everyday change?
A: No. Because the “S” mint mark indicates it was made at the San Francisco Mint exclusively as a proof coin for collectors, it was never put into general circulation. You’ll only find it in proof sets or through coin dealers and auctions.
Q: Does the coin need to be certified to be valuable?
A: Not necessarily. Raw (uncertified) examples in original proof set packaging still have solid collector value, especially in higher grades. However, if you believe your coin is a PR69 or PR70 Deep Cameo, professional certification from PCGS or NGC can significantly increase buyer confidence and sale price.
