The 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollar is worth anywhere from $1 to $5 in circulated condition, with uncirculated examples fetching $10 to $25 or more depending on mint mark and grade. If you found one in your change drawer or grandparent’s coin jar, you’re in the right place to learn exactly what it’s worth.
What Is the 2009 John Tyler Dollar Coin?
The 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollar was released as part of the United States Mint’s Presidential Dollar Program, which ran from 2007 to 2016. Each year, four presidents were honored in the order they served, and John Tyler — the 10th president of the United States — was among those featured in 2009. These coins are golden in color, made from a manganese brass alloy, and measure 26.5mm in diameter. They were minted at both the Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) mints for general circulation, as well as at San Francisco (S) for proof collector sets. If you’re not sure which mint struck your coin, using a best coin identifier app can help you quickly identify the mint mark and grade of your coin right from your phone. The mint mark is found on the edge of the coin, which is also where you’ll find the motto “E PLURIBUS UNUM” and the year of issue — a unique design feature of this entire series.
2009 J. Tyler Dollar Coin Value by Mint Mark and Grade
The value of your 2009 John Tyler dollar depends heavily on its condition and where it was minted. Coins pulled from everyday circulation are generally worth face value or just slightly above it. However, uncirculated and proof versions are where things get more interesting for collectors.
| Coin Type | Mint Mark | Circulated Value | Uncirculated (MS65) | Proof (PR69) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| John Tyler Dollar | P (Philadelphia) | $1–$2 | $8–$15 | — |
| John Tyler Dollar | D (Denver) | $1–$2 | $8–$15 | — |
| John Tyler Dollar Proof | S (San Francisco) | — | — | $15–$30 |
Keep in mind that coins graded MS67 or higher by PCGS or NGC can sell for $50 or more at auction, especially with strong eye appeal and no contact marks.
Are Any 2009 Tyler Dollars Worth More Because of Errors?
Yes — error coins can dramatically increase the value of an otherwise common Presidential Dollar. The most well-known error type across the Presidential Dollar series is the “missing edge lettering” variety. On normal coins, the edge is inscribed with the date, mint mark, and mottos. When that lettering is absent — either on one side or completely missing — the coin is considered an error and can be worth anywhere from $50 to $150 or more in uncirculated condition.
Another error to look for is a “doubled edge lettering” coin, where the inscriptions appear twice due to the coin being run through the edge-lettering machine more than once. These are rarer and similarly valuable. You can also compare your coin’s design details against known rare dollar coin value guides to understand how error premiums work across the broader dollar coin category. Always inspect your Tyler dollar carefully under good lighting or a loupe before dismissing it as common.
How to Get the Best Price for Your 2009 Tyler Dollar
If you believe your 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollar is in excellent condition or might be an error coin, getting it professionally graded is the smartest first step. PCGS and NGC are the two most trusted grading services in the hobby. A graded and slabbed coin sells for significantly more than a raw ungraded one, particularly when listing on eBay or submitting to auction houses.
For quick research on the go, CoinHix is a fantastic tool that helps everyday collectors check market prices instantly. Whether you’re at a flea market, estate sale, or just sorting through a jar of old coins, CoinHix gives you real-time pricing data so you never overpay or undersell. You can also browse current dollar coin price data across top mint state grades to see how collector demand shifts over time. For those building a complete Presidential Dollar set, the Tyler dollar is an affordable and historically meaningful addition to any collection.
Tips for Storing and Protecting Your Coin
Even if your 2009 Tyler dollar isn’t worth a fortune, proper storage helps preserve its value. Always handle coins by their edges, never the faces. Store them in acid-free coin flips, hard plastic holders, or 2×2 cardboard holders. Avoid cleaning your coins — even light polishing can permanently lower a coin’s grade and erase potential value. Use CoinHix regularly to monitor pricing trends so you’ll know the right time to sell if the market improves.
FAQ
Q: Is the 2009 John Tyler dollar coin made of silver or gold?
A: No. Despite its golden appearance, the 2009 J. Tyler Presidential Dollar is made of manganese brass — a copper-zinc-manganese-nickel alloy. It contains no silver or gold and is not a precious metal coin.
Q: How many 2009 Tyler dollars were minted?
A: The Philadelphia Mint struck approximately 43,540,000 Tyler dollars, and the Denver Mint produced around 43,540,000 as well. The high mintage makes most circulated examples common and worth close to face value.
Q: Where can I find the mint mark on my 2009 Tyler dollar?
A: The mint mark on Presidential Dollars is located on the edge of the coin, not the face. Look for a small “P,” “D,” or “S” stamped into the edge along with the year and national mottos. A magnifying glass can help you read it clearly.
