The 2010-S Millard Fillmore Presidential Dollar is worth anywhere from $2 to $3 in typical circulated condition, but proof versions struck at the San Francisco Mint can fetch $5 to $15 or more depending on grade and eye appeal. If you stumbled across one of these coins in a collection or gift set, you’re in the right place to find out exactly what it’s worth.
What Makes the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar Special
The 2010-S Millard Fillmore Dollar was struck exclusively at the San Francisco Mint as a proof coin, meaning it was never intended for everyday circulation. These coins were produced with special dies, polished planchets, and multiple strikes to create sharp detail and a mirror-like finish. They were sold directly to collectors through U.S. Mint subscription sets, so finding one in pocket change is essentially impossible.
Millard Fillmore, the 13th President of the United States, is featured on the obverse. The Presidential Dollar series ran from 2007 to 2016, honoring deceased presidents in the order they served. Fillmore joined the series in 2010 along with fellow presidents John Tyler, James K. Polk, and Zachary Taylor.
If you want to quickly identify a coin like this and get an instant estimate of its value, using the best coin identifier app can save you a lot of time and guesswork. These tools are especially helpful when you’re sorting through a large collection and need fast, reliable answers.
Mintage Numbers and Why They Matter
Mintage is one of the biggest factors that drives coin value. Lower production numbers generally mean fewer coins available to collectors, which pushes prices up over time. Here’s a quick look at the 2010 Presidential Dollar mintage figures across all mint facilities:
| Mint Mark | Type | Mintage | Typical Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2010-P | Business Strike | 37,520,000 | $1 to $2 |
| 2010-D | Business Strike | 36,960,000 | $1 to $2 |
| 2010-S | Proof | 1,689,216 | $5 to $15+ |
The 2010-S proof version has a significantly lower mintage than its Philadelphia and Denver counterparts, which is part of why collectors tend to place higher value on it. While none of these coins are rare in an absolute sense, the proof version has genuine collector appeal.
Grading the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar and How It Affects Value
Coin grading is the process of evaluating a coin’s condition on the Sheldon scale, which runs from 1 (Poor) to 70 (Perfect Uncirculated). For proof coins like the 2010-S Millard Fillmore Dollar, graders look for cameo contrast between the frosted devices and the mirror fields, as well as any hairlines, spots, or handling marks.
A standard proof example grades between PR65 and PR67 and is worth roughly $5 to $10. Coins that achieve a Deep Cameo designation — where the contrast is especially dramatic — can sell for $12 to $20 in grades of PR69DC. A perfect PR70DC example, certified by PCGS or NGC, can bring $30 to $50 from the right buyer.
CoinHix is a great tool for tracking current sale prices for graded examples. The app pulls real market data so you can see exactly what the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar is selling for right now, not just estimates from a printed price guide.
Where to Find Current Market Prices for the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar
Coin values shift based on collector demand, auction results, and broader market trends. The best way to know what your coin is worth today is to check recent sales. You can browse up-to-date pricing data for 2010 dollar coins across multiple grades and varieties to get a clearer picture of where values stand.
It’s also worth comparing multiple sources. For a solid breakdown of how condition affects value across the entire 2010 Sacagawea and Presidential Dollar issues, check out this detailed guide to 2010 dollar coin values by grade and mint mark.
eBay completed listings are another reliable resource. Filter for “sold” items to see actual transaction prices rather than wishful asking prices. CoinHix aggregates this kind of data and makes it easy to track without spending hours searching manually.
Is the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar Worth Keeping or Selling
For most people, the 2010-S Millard Fillmore Dollar is a modest but collectible coin. It’s not going to make you rich overnight, but a well-preserved proof set including this coin has real value to the right collector. If yours is still sealed in the original Mint packaging, keep it that way — handling or removing the coin can instantly reduce its grade and value.
If you have multiples or are looking to sell, local coin dealers, online auction sites, and collector forums are all solid options. Getting a professional grade from PCGS or NGC is worth considering if you believe your coin might score a PR69 or PR70, since certified top-pop examples consistently command premiums.
FAQ About the 2010-S Millard Fillmore Dollar
Q: How do I know if my 2010-S Fillmore Dollar is a proof coin?
A: Proof coins have an unmistakable mirror-like background and frosted raised design. The “S” mint mark confirms it was struck at the San Francisco Mint, which produced proofs exclusively for that year’s Presidential Dollar series.
Q: Can I find the 2010-S Fillmore Dollar in circulation?
A: No. The 2010-S proof version was sold only through U.S. Mint collector sets and was never released into general circulation. If you have one, it almost certainly came from a set or a previous collector.
Q: Is it worth getting my 2010-S Fillmore Dollar professionally graded?
A: It depends on the coin’s condition. For standard PR65 to PR67 examples, grading fees may exceed the coin’s market value. But if your coin shows deep cameo contrast and no visible flaws, aiming for a PR69DC or PR70DC certification through CoinHix-tracked auction comparisons could make grading worthwhile.
